Reading ability is very difficult to assess accurately.
In the communicative competence model, a student's reading level is the
level at which that student is able to use reading to accomplish
communication goals. This means that assessment of reading ability needs
to be correlated with purposes for reading.
Reading Aloud
A student's performance when reading aloud is not a reliable
indicator of that student's reading ability. A student who is perfectly
capable of understanding a given text when reading it silently may
stumble when asked to combine comprehension with word recognition and
speaking ability in the way that reading aloud requires.
In addition, reading aloud is a task that students will rarely,
if ever, need to do outside of the classroom. As a method of
assessment, therefore, it is not authentic: It does not test a student's
ability to use reading to accomplish a purpose or goal.
However, reading aloud can help a teacher assess whether a
student is "seeing" word endings and other grammatical features when
reading. To use reading aloud for this purpose, adopt the "read and look
up" approach: Ask the student to read a sentence silently one or more
times, until comfortable with the content, then look up and tell you
what it says. This procedure allows the student to process the text, and
lets you see the results of that processing and know what elements, if
any, the student is missing.
Comprehension Questions
Instructors often use comprehension questions to test whether
students have understood what they have read. In order to test
comprehension appropriately, these questions need to be coordinated with
the purpose for reading. If the purpose is to find specific
information, comprehension questions should focus on that information.
If the purpose is to understand an opinion and the arguments that
support it, comprehension questions should ask about those points.
In everyday reading situations, readers have a purpose for
reading before they start. That is, they know what comprehension
questions they are going to need to answer before they begin reading. To
make reading assessment in the language classroom more like reading
outside of the classroom, therefore, allow students to review the
comprehension questions before they begin to read the test passage.
Finally, when the purpose for reading is enjoyment,
comprehension questions are beside the point. As a more authentic form
of assessment, have students talk or write about why they found the text
enjoyable and interesting (or not).
Authentic Assessment
In order to provide authentic assessment of students' reading
proficiency, a post-listening activity must reflect the real-life uses
to which students might put information they have gained through
reading.
- It must have a purpose other than assessment
- It must require students to demonstrate their level of reading comprehension by completing some task
To develop authentic assessment activities, consider
the type of response that reading a particular selection would elicit
in a non-classroom situation. For example, after reading a weather
report, one might decide what to wear the next day; after reading a set
of instructions, one might repeat them to someone else; after reading a
short story, one might discuss the story line with friends.
Use this response type as a base for selecting appropriate
post-reading tasks. You can then develop a checklist or rubric that will
allow you to evaluate each student's comprehension of specific parts of
the text.